Master 2D Animation in Procreate Dreams: Basics for Digital Art vs Adobe After Effects: The Complete Beginner Course (All Versions)
Same Bayesian formula, same rubric — so the difference in scores reflects the difference in the courses, not the difference in how we evaluated them.
Domestika (Brookes Eggleston) · Design
Master 2D Animation in Procreate Dreams: Basics for Digital Art
Skillshare · Design
Adobe After Effects: The Complete Beginner Course (All Versions)
Per-criterion
The 26-lesson curriculum is well-sequenced, moving from the iPad and Procreate Dreams interface through drawing, perform mode, storyboarding and finally a full frame-by-frame animation project. Domestika reviewers repeatedly describe it as "concise, clear, beautiful" (fnannini) and praise that it "gets straight to practice" (ale_chio). The single largest content complaint, raised across multiple reviews, is that the course was filmed on an earlier build of Procreate Dreams; after the Dreams 2 update several reviewers noted the interface "no longer aligns with the current layout."
Brookes Eggleston brings over a decade of professional character design and animation experience plus a large teaching following from his Character Design Forge channel. Reviewers single out his pacing — neocesar wrote that he "explains well, goes step-by-step, it's great" — and one student called it "without a doubt the BEST course on Procreate Dreams found online." The main instructor-side complaint was isolated: juanugalde2003 flagged poor audio in the lessons, a production issue rather than a teaching one.
The course is sold on Domestika's low one-time pricing (frequently discounted to roughly $10–$20) with lifetime access, which reviewers consider strong value for nearly four hours of structured instruction. The bigger value question raised by blog reviewers concerns the app itself rather than the course: David Pike noted Procreate Dreams "for no subscription and all future updates included, isn't too expensive" at $12.99, while The Hiena cautioned "there are other better affordable tools on the market for animating on the iPad."
The course ends with a complete short animation and a unit on portfolio and personal branding, which gives beginners a shareable deliverable. Forum and blog reviewers confirm the skills transfer: the perform-mode and frame-by-frame techniques taught are the genuine Procreate Dreams workflow. The limitation is the app's own ceiling — reviewers like The Hiena flag missing speed graphs and serious animators note that rigging/bones-based pipelines (David Pike) are not covered, so the course prepares you for short 2D pieces rather than studio production.
Domestika courses include a discussion forum and the ability to share project work, which beginners use to get feedback. However, the most pointed criticism in the data is the absence of course updates: jmattcreative directly asked "will this course be updated at all now that there is a complete new update to Procreate Dreams?" and that question appears unanswered across multiple recent reviews. There is no live mentorship, and the perform-mode and gesture-driven workflows that the app hides behind menus are exactly where beginners report needing more hand-holding.
The course delivers a complete beginner arc across roughly 22 lessons and about four hours of video: the After Effects interface, compositions, layers, keyframes and animation basics, masking, effects, and a capstone "Morph" visual-effects project. Class Central's listing carries a 4.7 rating across 20 Skillshare ratings, and the cross-listed Udemy edition holds 4.3/5 from 265 reviews — consistent signals that the curriculum is accurate and well-scoped for absolute beginners. Reviewers on CourseDuck repeatedly describe it as "great beginners course with plenty of exercises" and praise its clear, project-based structure. The main content limitation, named by multiple learners, is that it stops at the beginner ceiling: students like David Sadleir and Paw Pedersen explicitly asked for an intermediate follow-up because the class ends just as they wanted to go deeper.
Tobias of Surfaced Studio is the standout dimension. He has produced After Effects and VFX "edutainment" for over a decade, with a YouTube following north of 300,000 subscribers, and his teaching philosophy is that training should be both educational and entertaining. CourseDuck reviewer John Nelson calls him "a highly entertaining and knowledgeable instructor," and Gordon Riley goes further: "Hands down the best instructor for After Effects and Adobe Premiere, and this course is no exception." Review blogs single out his explanations as "the most articulate, funniest, and most clearly presented" in the After Effects space. He focuses on teaching not just which button to press but why a given tool fits a given task — the mark of an instructor building transferable intuition rather than recipe-following.
On Skillshare the class is covered by the standard subscription (around $14/month or ~$168/year, frequently discounted, with a free trial), which gives access not only to this course but to Surfaced Studio's other classes and the entire Skillshare catalog. For a learner who wants a single, well-produced four-hour foundation before branching into the platform's thousands of motion and design classes, that is strong value. The same course also exists on Udemy as a paid one-time purchase and free on Surfaced Studio's own academy, so price-sensitive learners have options — but inside the Skillshare subscription model the cost-per-hour of instruction here is genuinely low.
The course is explicitly project-based: every section builds toward the hands-on Morph VFX final project, and CourseDuck reviewers note it comes "with plenty of exercises." Beginner Dorian Lambert, with no prior video editing experience, reported following along and "made the Morph effect with ease," which is exactly the outcome a project-based beginner course should produce. The limitation is breadth: it is a focused four-hour class with one capstone, not a sprawling library of drills. Learners who want dozens of standalone exercises or repeated practice projects will finish this and immediately want more — which is why so many reviews end with a request for an intermediate sequel.
For a skills course, the relevant "outcome" is confidence and capability, and the review record is strong here. Reviewer Melissa described After Effects as initially "very daunting and difficult" and credited the course with making her "completely comfortable with After Effects." Hadeel Abobakr Baazim called it "a very useful course that made me very comfortable with adobe after effect," and absolute beginners with no editing background report completing the capstone successfully. The consistency of "went from intimidated to comfortable in four hours" across independent reviewers is the clearest evidence the course reliably moves true beginners to a functional baseline.
Scoring methodology applies identically to every course on the site — see the formula.