CourseVerdict

Notion Masterclass: Maximise Your Productivity & Organisation vs Excel Essential Training (Microsoft 365)

Same Bayesian formula, same rubric — so the difference in scores reflects the difference in the courses, not the difference in how we evaluated them.

Skillshare · Business & Marketing

Notion Masterclass: Maximise Your Productivity & Organisation

4.1/ 5 · 38 opinions
24 positive8 neutral6 negative/ 38 total

LinkedIn Learning · Dennis Taylor · Business & Marketing

Excel Essential Training (Microsoft 365)

4.1/ 5 · 40 opinions
28 positive8 neutral4 negative/ 40 total

Per-criterion

Content quality4.2 / 5

24 lessons across fundamentals, databases, relations, rollups and a LifeOS dashboard. Praised for clarity and the database section. Capped because 1h45m is brisk for a full LifeOS build and cannot match Marie Poulin's depth.

Instructor4.3 / 5

Ali Abdaal is one of the most-watched productivity instructors on YouTube and reviewers describe him as warm, clear and motivating. Critics on Hacker News flag his content as anxiety-inducing and his LifeOS as overcomplex.

Value for money4.6 / 5

Included in Skillshare's ~$14/month subscription, plus 10+ free Notion templates built exclusively for Skillshare students. Cited on HN as the canonical case of a productivity creator earning $40-60k/month from Skillshare.

Practical frameworks4.0 / 5

The LifeOS dashboard, relations-and-rollups walkthrough and weekly review structure are the most reused frameworks. Capped because the eight-database system is heavy and reviewers report copying templates verbatim.

Real-world use3.8 / 5

Notion fluency and database design transfer directly to marketing and ops roles, and Abdaal uses the same setup to run a 15-person business. Limit is overhead — several HN commenters describe abandoning Notion systems built this way.

Content quality4.1 / 5

Clear, well-paced and current — the 2025 Microsoft 365 refresh covers PivotTables, charts, multi-sheet formulas and Microsoft Copilot inside Excel. Depth stops at "essential," so power users wanting Power Query, dynamic arrays or VBA outgrow it quickly.

Instructor4.5 / 5

Dennis Taylor has taught Excel on this platform since the Lynda.com era. Reviewers reach for the same words — calm, clear, methodical. The 4.7-star aggregate from 8,000+ LinkedIn Learning ratings reflects unusually consistent praise for delivery.

Value for money3.9 / 5

Bundled in the LinkedIn Learning subscription (~$40/month or via LinkedIn Premium). HN commenters repeatedly flag that most US public libraries offer free LinkedIn Learning access via library card — which moves this to effectively free for many readers.

Practical frameworks3.8 / 5

Coherent walkthrough of the daily Excel surface — data entry, formulas, formatting, charts, PivotTables, multi-workbook references, Copilot prompts. Stops short of the analyst-grade stack — Power Query, Power Pivot, dynamic arrays, LAMBDA — driving modern Excel work.

Real-world use4.0 / 5

Excel is one of the most universally job-applicable skills in business, and Taylor's coverage maps cleanly onto what finance, ops, marketing and admin touch daily. Ceiling — data-analyst roles still need Power Query and deeper pivots this course barely touches.

Scoring methodology applies identically to every course on the site — see the formula.