Adobe InDesign CC – Essentials Training Course vs Adobe Illustrator CC – Advanced Training
Same Bayesian formula, same rubric — so the difference in scores reflects the difference in the courses, not the difference in how we evaluated them.
Udemy · Design
Adobe InDesign CC – Essentials Training Course
Daniel Walter Scott (Udemy) · Design
Adobe Illustrator CC – Advanced Training
Per-criterion
Around 7 hours and ~78 lessons take a complete beginner from the InDesign interface through type, colour, master pages, frames, automatic tables of contents, data merge and professional print/PDF export. Reviewers call it well-paced and "straight-to-the-point" with no padding. Capped because it is essentials-only and the recordings predate the current CC interface in places.
Daniel Walter Scott is an Adobe Certified Instructor and Adobe Certified Expert, a multi-award winner and speaker at Adobe Max with 15+ years teaching. He is the single most-cited reason to take the course — students across Udemy, CourseDuck and CreativeLive consistently call him clear, patient, enthusiastic and never boring. The course's clearest strength.
Effective Udemy sale price of roughly $15-19 (full list ~$100+ is rarely paid) buys ~7 hours, five real publication projects, downloadable exercise files, lifetime access and free updates. One reviewer said it is "worth so much more than you pay on Udemy." The same content also lives on Skillshare and as InDesign Fundamentals on CreativeLive at different price models.
Project-driven throughout: learners build a flyer, a newsletter/brochure, a long annual-report-style document and conference name badges, leaving with five portfolio pieces. Outputs are competent beginner publications rather than client-grade deliverables, which is right for an essentials course. Real artwork-to-print workflow rather than isolated feature demos.
Teaches the genuine desktop-publishing workflow — master pages, styles, data merge, packaging and print/PDF export — that a junior designer or production artist actually uses. Skills transfer directly to print and layout work. Ceiling is that InDesign itself is a niche, print-leaning tool, so applicability depends heavily on the kind of design work you want.
Covers the full advanced Illustrator toolset — pen tool mastery, complex paths, advanced typography, colour theory, logo design, packaging, pattern design, and complex illustration workflows. The curriculum is dense without being padded; reviewers describe it as genuinely comprehensive for the intermediate-to-advanced level. The main gap is limited coverage of screen-first digital workflows (UI, web) relative to the depth given to print and vector.
Daniel Walter Scott is an Adobe Certified Instructor and Adobe Certified Expert with over 16 years of design experience. His teaching is praised across thousands of reviews as crystal clear, professionally paced, and attentive to the edge cases where learners get stuck. The Adobe certification is not cosmetic — it translates into accurate, current, and authoritative instruction on the tool.
Priced at $19.99 on frequent Udemy sale (the effective purchase price for nearly all students) for a comprehensive advanced course with real-world projects and lifetime access. At sale price this is the strongest value-per-hour advanced design course available on any major platform. Full list price ($100+) is never what anyone pays, which matters for how you should think about the Udemy pricing model.
Multiple real-world projects throughout — logo design, packaging mock-ups, pattern systems, complex vector illustration — rather than isolated exercises. Reviewers describe finishing the course with a small body of work they can use in a portfolio. Some exercises feel more like skill-drills than finished pieces, but the balance across the curriculum is strong.
The skills covered — pen tool precision, colour systems, typography workflows, file structure for print — are what working graphic designers and illustrators use daily. Reviewers in professional design roles describe the course as directly applicable to client work. The print and vector orientation limits applicability for UI/UX designers whose primary output is screen-first.
Scoring methodology applies identically to every course on the site — see the formula.