CourseVerdict

Graphic Design Masterclass - Learn GREAT Design vs The Beginner's Guide to Adobe After Effects

Same Bayesian formula, same rubric — so the difference in scores reflects the difference in the courses, not the difference in how we evaluated them.

Udemy · Design

Graphic Design Masterclass - Learn GREAT Design

4.4/ 5 · 56 opinions
41 positive10 neutral5 negative/ 56 total

Skillshare · Design

The Beginner's Guide to Adobe After Effects

4.3/ 5 · 35 opinions
26 positive7 neutral2 negative/ 35 total

Per-criterion

Content quality4.5 / 5

A genuinely broad beginner-to-intermediate curriculum — typography, colour theory, layout and composition, photo editing, magazine layout, branding and logo design, plus the basics of Photoshop, Illustrator and InDesign across 16+ hours of video. Praised for blending design theory with software, not just one or the other. Capped because the same breadth means no single topic (type, branding, motion) gets specialist depth.

Instructor4.6 / 5

Lindsay Marsh is the most-cited strength across our corpus — calm, clear, well-paced, and good at breaking theory into digestible segments. Two decades of freelance brand work give her real credibility. The one recurring caveat reviewers raise is that her background is freelance and small-to-medium brands rather than large-enterprise design teams.

Value for money4.7 / 5

The strongest dimension. A 16+ hour project-based course that lists at ~$200 but realistically sells for ~$12 during Udemy's near-constant sales, with lifetime access, certificate of completion and downloadable templates. For the sale price the value case is hard to argue with — the main caveat is the well-known Udemy price-anchoring discount theatre.

Portfolio output4.3 / 5

Real-world projects (magazine layouts, logo work, branding exercises) build a beginner portfolio and are the part learners credit most for making the theory stick. Downloadable templates support each project. Capped because Udemy offers no graded submission or peer critique — you complete projects alone with no structured feedback loop.

Real-world use4.2 / 5

Learners report the fundamentals and software workflows transfer directly to freelance and junior design work, and recent updates add current skills like Photoshop generative fill. Limit is that a single Udemy certificate is not a hiring credential on its own, and the course does not cover client process, pricing or the business of running design work.

Content quality4.3 / 5

34 lessons across approximately 5 hours cover the After Effects workspace, composition, keyframing, masks, shape layers, text animation, and effects in a logical build. Reviewers consistently describe the progression as genuinely systematic — each lesson builds directly on the previous one rather than jumping between topics. The main gap is that the course ends where intermediate motion design begins; no expressions, no rigging.

Instructor4.6 / 5

Jake Bartlett has been teaching After Effects since 2013 and has 30+ courses on Skillshare. The dominant praise is that he explains *why* you are doing each step, not just the button sequence to press. Students consistently describe his instruction as gap-filling — knowledge they had been missing about AE falls into place quickly. Pacing is brisk but never rushed.

Value for money4.4 / 5

Covered under a standard Skillshare membership ($168/year or first month free trial). For the breadth and quality of 34 lessons of motion design instruction, the value-per-lesson under a membership is excellent. The caveat is that After Effects itself requires a separate Creative Cloud subscription ($55+/month), which is the real cost of learning the tool.

Portfolio output3.8 / 5

The single final project — a 'Taco Tuesday' arcade-style animation — is fun and motivating as a through-line. Reviewers enjoy completing it and find it a coherent showcase of the skills covered. It is, however, a playful exercise rather than a professional portfolio showpiece; its game-show aesthetic does not translate directly into a reel.

Real-world use4.2 / 5

After Effects is the industry standard tool for motion graphics, broadcast, and digital content production. The foundational skills covered — layer animation, timing, masks, effects — transfer directly to real client work. Reviewers in motion design and video production describe the course skills as the exact foundation they use professionally. The gap is that the course does not reach expressions or templates, which are daily tools in professional AE workflows.

Scoring methodology applies identically to every course on the site — see the formula.