Modern React with Redux vs JavaScript: The Hard Parts, v2
Same Bayesian formula, same rubric — so the difference in scores reflects the difference in the courses, not the difference in how we evaluated them.
Udemy · Web Development
Modern React with Redux
Frontend Masters · Web Development
JavaScript: The Hard Parts, v2
Per-criterion
The standout is Grider's diagram-driven explanation. Reviewers repeatedly praise how he explains everything "bit by bit" with custom mockups and visuals, and deliberately walks through common mistakes before the preferred fix. The catch: at 75+ hours some sections cover older class-component and legacy Redux material learners no longer need.
Grider is one of the most consistently praised instructors on Udemy. Across blogs and Hacker News, developers call his courses "outstanding" and say his style is exceptionally clear. The 4.7 Udemy rating across ~89,000 ratings reflects this. The only recurring note is that his slow, thorough pace does not suit everyone.
On Udemy's frequent sales (~$15), 75+ hours of well-structured, frequently updated content is a strong deal, and reviewers say it is "worth every penny." It still loses a little because part of that runtime is legacy material, so the effective value is high but not every hour is essential.
The course is hands-on and project-based, which most learners value. But the most common criticism is that it lacks real challenges — the projects are largely follow-along, with no exercises where the student must implement features alone. Some also flag unexplained Bootstrap styling that complicated their own later builds.
It covers modern, employable React — hooks, Context, React Router, TypeScript, and Redux Toolkit in recent updates — and developers report it genuinely prepared them. The honest gap is depth on testing and the lingering legacy Redux sections, which can leave beginners unsure which patterns are current.
Goes deep on the JavaScript runtime model — thread of execution, the call stack, closure, the event loop, Promises and prototypes/classes — across roughly 6.5 hours. Reviewers consistently say it explains how JavaScript works "under the hood" rather than just syntax.
Will Sentance (Codesmith founder) is the most-praised element. Learners cite his blackboard diagrams, the "backpack" analogy for closure, and a Socratic, audience-paced delivery. The same intense, repetitive style is the one thing a minority find tiring.
Requires a $39/month Frontend Masters subscription rather than a one-time purchase — strong value if you use the wider catalog, weaker if you only want this one course. The course is included in the standard subscription.
This is a conceptual, exercise-and-whiteboard course, not a project build. There is no portfolio-worthy capstone, which some learners miss. The exercises are effective for drilling mental models but produce no artefact.
The mental models — call stack, closure, the event loop, async behaviour — directly explain bugs developers hit daily. Experienced developers report the course clarified concepts they had used for years without fully understanding.
Scoring methodology applies identically to every course on the site — see the formula.